> do you really want to prove your credibility to the world with a commit history like this
> do you seriously want to eternalize yourself with this ridiculous commits?
Credibility? Eternalize?
What? Look - I'm just a FOSS coder and I don't care how "professional" or
whatever I come across. What I do care about is an /honest/ track record
that can be seen in my github profile, amongst other things. I would
like to help out in other projects as well, eventually, and I want to be able to offer an honest, cohesive picture of how past efforts went about.
That's why I showed you what I did for RedBean - to give you a direct
view into how it went down in another example. If I propose help to other projects, I don't think they would care much about how "professional" I am, but they would very much appreciate an honest picture of the process.
This may seem like a fine
point (and I suppose both sides look equally silly in standing up for
something that may appear minor to outsiders) but just as you have to
stand up for your history, I have to stand up for mine. And I'm willing to do that. I have told you,
rather clearly, that it is important to me to have it this way and that
it is your choice to weigh the options. I consider it a small price to
pay, particularly since many of the technical issues noted can be
solved, sometimes with something as simple as a '-w'. More importantly
though, I consider the price you would have to pay smaller than the one
I'm paying.
I understand that my efforts are
appreciated by you and so far, I was happy with how the process went,
even if I had to make some compromises to points that I originally
didn't think were debatable. But I think it's not unreasonable of me to make one or two smaller requirements myself.
Anyways, I'm getting a sense that this is really mostly about commit /messages/. Well alright then. What about if I simply rename those commits? Would be a bit of rebasing, but from my count, there's only about 15 commits that lack a good commit message. Would that be an agreeable compromise?