On Jan 16, 2013, at 3:38 PM, Michael Heydekamp listuser@freexp.de wrote:
Am 16.01.2013 12:42, schrieb Cor Bosman:
Mail-Reply-To: michael Reply-To: michael, RCU
The response will only go to michael, and not to the list unless you do reply-all.
But then it still doesn't go "michael", THAT's the issue.
Right next to the Reply-All button, there is a small carrot pointing down. If you select that, and then "Reply-All" you will reply to both. So this functionality does exist in roundcube. Not saying thats perfect, but it's there.
Or just one of the issues, as it will be expected by a) the sender and b) the RC user that a reply will go to ALL addresses contained in the "Reply-To:" header.
But i dont necessarily see that as a problem, because thats what he told roundcube to do in the roundcube settings.
No, please see previous message. It IS a problem.
You say, that when someone adds their own Reply-To in roundcube settings, somehow they intent to have replies go to both the list AND that address. Why? I would say they mean that all replies should go to just that reply-to address. Seeing as we already dont agree on what it's supposed to do, you can count on people wanting different things from it :)
If you still can't see it, please answer the following: Why should Mailman add the list address to the "Reply-To:" header, if it wouldn't want to make sure that any reply shall also go to the list?
Mailman doesnt. This is a conscious decision by the list owner. Read this:
http://www.gnu.org/software/mailman/mailman-admin/node11.html
Especially read the second sentence. Trust me, this isnt the first time this discussion has been done. It is a constant and endless difference of opinion.
And I also want to point you to this sentence:
"When you set this variable to Poster, no additional Reply-To: header will be added by Mailman. This setting is strongly recommended."
Here you see that Mailman ITSELF recommends not adding the list address to the reply-to. The reason for this is that people dont want to get 2 replies of the same message, something you seem to want. You're in a minority.
Anyways, im not even sure the mailinglist software sets the Reply-To here, or if RC does on reply.
Cor