First off, as a user, I like the idea of the spam *not* being in my inbox when I log in. If it's marked as such by spamassassin, then I don't care to see it. Get it away from my legit mail and let me sort through it in my Junk folder, where it belongs.

Secondly, I actually have integration of spamassassin for SQL and non-SQL userpref's installs into roundcube. The non-SQL userprefs set-up uses a combination of setuid C & Perl code that handled the userprefs file on the OS (tried to secure it as much as possible). I also integrated a new tab on the user settings page that looks like the attached screen shot. If people are interested enough, I could lift that code and port it to the most recent stable for public consumption, minus the non-SQL userprefs set-up... I also have two folders that get created on first login called Whitelist and Blacklist. If messages are moved to those folders, the appropriate action is taken (added to whitelist or blacklist, respectively). Whitelist actually performs two actions with this set-up; whitelists the sender and runs the message through sa-learn. I had it set-up like this because I used roundcube for a "Spam Quarantine" type set-up.

Thoughts?

FWIW on the sa-learn thoughts, you could write a cron job that scans the user's Junk folder nightly and run those messages through sa-learn.

~ Ben

On 12/14/06, Tomasz Pajor t.pajor@aisak.pl wrote:

I personally think, that it would be a good idea to move spam on login to spam folder. As it goes for all other things that you mensioned, I agree.

-- Best regards Tomasz Pajor

On Thu, 14 Dec 2006 15:30:59 +0000, roundcube-dev@alldesign.de wrote:

...

Hi,

first i'm new one here. good project. i decided to work a little bit

for.

...

What's your opinion what RoundCube could / should do with Spam. I found

a

...

ticket for that and i decided to solve this. The Question is, what does RoundCube should do. I think to move / show SPAM-Flag: yes Messages move to the Junk directly is not the best think and not the job from Roundcube.

So i add some things to my feature list.

• Color the Messages (brown) in Inbox if the are spam. Over Spamassassin

Junk Stars, but other milter are also possible.

• Add a button to move it to junk folder.
• On Moving to junk folder it possible to run sa-learn with user

settings

...

for bayes.

• Is also possible to set up this work automaticly (move spam to

junkfolder on login), but only with imap.

• Set up Spamassassin user Setting via file oder mysql databases

(supports

...

also confixx)

I try also to programm a filter thats identify also Newsletter or other Messagetypes and color it (grey)

Many thanks to guzu, he's on the right way.

I'm afraid to here more opinion and wishes for that.

Thanks

This feature seems to be discussed every so often on this list (if you want to see the discussion, search the archives). While I'm sure most people will agree that spam filtering is a very important feature, it has been decided to push off implementing anything officially until RC has plugin support since there are so many different spam filtering methods.

Adam

On 12/14/06, Ryan Rittenhouse ryanmr@goshen.edu wrote:

Just an idea, feel free to shoot it down ... why not implement user configurable filters in general, then you can have a rule packaged w/ roundcube to shuttle spam somewhere. That you way you get user configurable spam control and custom filters in one shot.

just my $0.02

-Ryan

Network Administrator Goshen College (574) 535-7004

Tomasz Pajor wrote:

...

I personally think, that it would be a good idea to move spam on login to spam folder. As it goes for all other things that you mensioned, I agree.

-- Best regards Tomasz Pajor

On Thu, 14 Dec 2006 15:30:59 +0000, roundcube-dev@alldesign.de wrote:

...

Hi,

first i'm new one here. good project. i decided to work a little bit for.

What's your opinion what RoundCube could / should do with Spam. I found a ticket for that and i decided to solve this. The Question is, what does RoundCube should do. I think to move / show SPAM-Flag: yes Messages move to the Junk directly is not the best think and not the job from Roundcube.

So i add some things to my feature list.

• Color the Messages (brown) in Inbox if the are spam. Over Spamassassin

Junk Stars, but other milter are also possible.

• Add a button to move it to junk folder.
• On Moving to junk folder it possible to run sa-learn with user settings

for bayes.

• Is also possible to set up this work automaticly (move spam to

junkfolder on login), but only with imap.

• Set up Spamassassin user Setting via file oder mysql databases (supports

also confixx)

I try also to programm a filter thats identify also Newsletter or other Messagetypes and color it (grey)

Many thanks to guzu, he's on the right way.

I'm afraid to here more opinion and wishes for that.

Thanks